PDA

View Full Version : Opinion: Kitchenware Forums



sleekay
10-20-2012, 07:34 AM
Hi everyone.

Would like to pick your brains! I love this forum for knife information - you helped me get two great knives (Suisin/Takeda) - I have seen the light!

I've been looking for a good kitchenware forum, where I can learn about kitchen tools: casserole dishes, sieves etc.


Does anyone have any recommendations?


Thanks for reading!
sleekay

Marko Tsourkan
10-20-2012, 08:11 AM
I think you can get a quality advice here on any kitchen related items. Why look elsewhere?
A person who invests into a good knife, is even more likely to invest into a good casserole, pots, dishes and sieves.
I can't speak for everybody, but is is my impression that this is a case.

M

Von blewitt
10-20-2012, 08:21 AM
I think you can get a quality advice here on any kitchen related items. Why look elsewhere?
A person who invests into a good knife, is even more likely to invest into a good casserole, pots, dishes and sieves.
I can't speak for everybody, but is is my impression that this is a case.

M

I agree, post a question in the off topic room, I would be amazed if you didn't get an answer to any kitchen/ cooking related question!

mr drinky
10-20-2012, 12:19 PM
There are other forums out there, but frankly some of them get really annoying to interact on. Chowhound has the same question asked over and over and over and has tons of users and traffic (good and bad). In each Chow forum there are the equivalent of ham radio operators dispatching advice as soon as a post pops up so discussions often end up with the same people talking about the same thing. With that said, the people on the cookwkare portion of the form who contribute the most are also knife nuts, though I think only a few of them are on this board too and they might not be that active. Chowhound is a lot of home cook foodies with about half of the comments crap IMO. The interesting thing is that if you ask a knife question there it usually ends up talking about Japanese knives and sharpening stones. Not a bad thing.

eGullet was the standard but is becoming irrelevant in many of its forums (low traffic) except some regional ones, the alcohol boards, and the molecular gastronomy (probably a few others too). Their pedigree though, is excellent. Grant Achatz was posting on their boards when he was dreaming up Alinea and Nathan Myhrvold also used the forum extensively when putting together his tome, Modernist Cuisine. Chad Ward, a knife nut, also started his book on knives as an instructional on eGullet. But the moderators can be snobby and are crazy when it comes to new posts and merging them with older ones. And the head of it all (Fat Guy) seems like an a-hole IMO. eGullet also had a blow out of grand proportions a while back that makes the KnifeForum fiasco look like a picnic.

With that said, eGullet has a lot of industry users so you get more Chef recommendations and with Chow you get more home cook recs. Searching past posts on both is valuable at times. There are other forums too like ChefTalk which seems to be getting better and also geared to the pro cook. Cooks Illustrated has an older baking demographic it seems, and I find it mostly worthless.

The advice on this forum is usually spot on with little garbage advice to sort through, so it is more efficient I think. If you post here and don't get many replies it might be good to search the other forums too. The search function on most forums sucks though (including this one). Chow is pretty good though and eGullet recently upgraded their site, so it is now better.

Just some rambling.

k.

El Pescador
10-20-2012, 12:37 PM
Well put Dinky! My sister has recently settled down and was looking for advice on cooking so she aske me about forums and I pointed her toward Chow hound. Most of the time, like all things online, I reminded her to take everything she reads with a grain of salt.

RobinW
10-20-2012, 02:22 PM
Maybe we should have a cookware subforum here? I like the idea!

SpikeC
10-20-2012, 05:11 PM
I use this forum for cooking related things at least as much as for knife stuff. The combination of pros and avid home cooks is hard to beat!

GlassEye
10-20-2012, 05:40 PM
Anyone who will spend $1k on a knife and use it hard likely also cares just as much about food, cooking, cookware, etc. I see no reason to go elsewhere.

mhlee
10-20-2012, 05:58 PM
I'd say kitchenware questions are kind of welcomed here. We only happen to have a 22 page thread related to De Buyer pans . . . :lol2:

sleekay
10-20-2012, 07:01 PM
Hi everyone! Thanks for all the great posts - they're appreciated! And thanks Mr. Dinky for all of the details - really appreciated.

I guess this is a great place to post my kitchen-related questions!

Thanks again!
sleekay

Johnny.B.Good
10-20-2012, 07:05 PM
I guess this is a great place to post my kitchen-related questions!

I like kitchenware conversations; I say post away!

SpikeC
10-20-2012, 07:16 PM
We have had many discussions about cast iron cookware, steel pans, juicers, pressure cookers, and spoons. Ten there are the soufflés!

The BoardSMITH
10-20-2012, 07:38 PM
I agree with Mr Drinky about Chow. I post there on occasion and when a poster tries to skewer me for a point, the post is left alone. If I try to reply, my posts are deleted.