I would agree with the post above, that knives at schools can walk away if you aren't keeping an eye on them 100% of the time especially something flashy.
I made it through school with MAC and Victorinox, and a ceramic honing rod. My knives were 10x sharper than what just about anyone else was carrying, (most people had Mercer kits that our bookstore sold). I'm in my last quarter getting ready to start a job and am now doing some research to get myself a nice knife or two (or maybe 20...) and some sharpening equipment.
The one thing I'm glad I spent the money on for school was a Thermapen. I still get asked to let someone borrow it at least once a day.
i have used, Konosuke, Geshin Ginga, Shigefusa, yoshikane SKD and SLD, Kato, Suisin Inox, and DT 52100 WA handle.
western handle i have used, Hattori FH, Carbonext, some JCK original brand.
i like them all, they all have their + and -
mostly i use the Yoshikane SKD, the edge last forever, i would probably recommend Shigefusa, but in a pro kitchen they need some care and knowledge to use, better to buy them later on, some of the students (and me) use Carbonext, not WA handle but great knives to start with. Konosuke to thin in my taste, great knife to slice and use for proteins, allround knife is for me a 210mm Gyuto and a 190mm-210mm Suji/petty.
i have bought Yoshikane from a couple of vendors, both thin and "normal" thick and they all suit my needs.
i like a pretty knife, dont get me wrong, they look great and you can probably convince 90% that "that" knife is good, but in the end as a Cuisine student/pro is performance and maintance that counts. normaly most people like stainless and semi stainless because they are more easy to handle in action, but for me Carbon is much easier to sharpen and funny to use on stones.
i would use 60% of my budget on 2-3 knives, no more, you dont need more knives at the start, 30% on stones, 1000 # grit, and 3000 -4000 # grit, to maintain the knife, 10% to save for the "monster" you always wanted :D
a normal day in the kitchen for me, i use a petty 180-210mm 20%, 210-240mm gyuto 60% suji and bonning knife 10% the rest 10 % cheap victorinox pairing knife, breadknife. a lot of people think they need a lot of knives (dont get me wrong, i have many, a lot i dont use, because im a knife nut) but in a pro kitchen you dont have the time to pick a sertain knife, you grab the one you like.
Thermapen is a great tool, i love it :D, but my students are not allowed to use them until they know how to feel the difference between blue, rare, medium and ruined meat. when they know how to cook meat, they are more than welcome to use the Thermapen, and with a pen you can always perform, not to forgett about Sous vide, with that and a vacuum you can never fail, but again, its not for students, they have to learn it the right way.
I'd consider an Ashi/Yusuke, etc out of white #2. These are very good cutters, tough and sharpen up super easily.
Originally Posted by foreleft
Originally Posted by tschmelcher
So now I have questions about sharpening tools. :)
Does she just need a few stones of different grits or is a strop also important?
Is a honing rod also beneficial or is it just a cheaper/lower-quality method?
What kind of knife would benefit from a 10,000 grit stone as the final sharpening step?
All I would recommend for a beginning culinary student is a knife like a Fujiwara Fkm, a carbonext or a Hiromoto AS, and a 1000 grit stone. Add a higher level stone when you are really proficient with the 1000.
I use a strop to touch-up and to help de-burr while sharpening, but it's not necessary, and not ideal in a commercial environment. I also didn't get one until I'd been using j-knives for about three years.
10,000 grit stones and high level finishing stones are mostly for sashimi knives or razors. Your girlfriend will probably end up with a couple of them if she becomes a knife Knut. ;)
. A ceramic rod could be handy as well. Not just a shortcut, but a good way to extend time between sharpenings. It's important to use good technique.
Originally Posted by DK chef
I would not get here a good or custom knife right out of the gate, a TKC or carbonext is a start.I say get her a entry level blade with a nice note promising her a custom in the future.