Your Three Cheapest knives that ACTUALLY performed

Kitchen Knife Forums

Help Support Kitchen Knife Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Lefty

Canada's Sharpest Lefty
Joined
Mar 31, 2011
Messages
6,477
Reaction score
9
The "regrettable purchases" thread made me think about which crap knives, or insane bargains have worked out the best for you.

My top three bargain buys are:

$5 Kiwi Nakiri
€10 Icel Petty/gyuto
$25 Fujiwara FKH 120(ish) petty

Honorable mention goes to a Yamawaku nakiri, Global G2 chef, and my Boker King Cutter straight that I found at the St. Lawrence Market for all of $10 :) I think it was never sharpened, and stropped a handful of times in its 75 or so years.

So, how about you guys?
 
Dexter Carbon Steel Chinese Cleaver - originally purchased years ago for about $23 or so.
Stainless Japanese paring knife - $25
Dexter Russell fillet knife with the blade height ground down and reshaped to my spec - less than $20.

I love these knives. If I had to, I know I could survive with only these three knives.
 
Can't really think of 3, so just the one. Eden VG10 parer. Cost me £22.50 and it is great value, especially for a linen micarta handle, damascus pattern and VG10. Can't complain at all
 
I don't know if the CCK counts, but it should. The other obvious choice is the $5 victorinox paring knife that I love.
 
Mac Superior santoku parer, think I paid $26 new...wifeys favorite.
Forschner serrated parer. Paid $3 new...definately got my moneys worth out of it.
Not a kitchen knife, but fits in good value/ use from a cheapie...
Opinel carbone #5 pocket knife. Paid $7 new...opened one million and one boxes with it. Keens up with ease, nice and thin, and carbon to boot.
 
I forgot about our two Victorinox parers. Actually, my wife's 3 parer choices were all very cheap. That is, or course, until her first custom comes in :D I think I'm more excited about it than she is! Haha
 
A Ran Damascus parer I got off Amazon for $35 - VG-10 damascus, and every bit as good as the only Shun people like. I let a friend talk me into selling it to him.

A Kanemasa 12 cm petty I got for $20, shipped.

A Sabatier Yatagan carving knife for $25. This one is going to a friend, too.
 
1. CCK 1303 cost about $30.00
2. Forgecraft 8" chefs. Cost: $20-25.00
3. Old Hickory bull nosed butcher (best thing for breaking down chicken, beats the laser thin stuff hands down imo) Cost $10.00

Honorably Mention
1. Miracle blade steak knives-better than wusthoff, henckels....at a fraction of the price.
2. Vicky paring-cost $2.50-5.00
 
Just one, as the rest of my now-unused collection is made up of knives that have an inverse proportion of price to performance.

My $9 KAI PureKomachi2 "bread" knife was a terrific bargain. After a year of regular use it has been relegated to sandwich knife duties while I enjoy my Henry-handled Tojiro ITK 270 bread knife. I only hope that Mike's epoxy lets go when the time comes to replace the blade! It is truly an incredible performer at the Tojiro's regular selling price of less than $70 including shipping.
 
Fujiwara FKH 120mm petty $35
Eskilstuna 270mm scimitar in 12c27 $6
Cladded carbon 160mm practice knife from jns $6
 
Ok, where do I get an Eskilstuna scimitar for $6???
 
Yes, and can I get one re-handled by you for $6.00?
 
Lefty: I found it on a Swedish auction-site, wasn't she a beauty? :D
photodec01222715.png


Kaleb: If you find one and manage to catch me in a weak moment(post-whiskey) maybe! :lol2:
 
I agree on the kiwi. I love mine, great little knife
The American Grinding 12" chefs I bought from lefty, best 25$ I've ever spent
My CCK 1303 of course, is now my go to workhorse
Old as dirt little cleaver I bought at antique mall. Not sure who its from, a can't remember what I paid, by after a little work, performs great
Vic paring
 
I can't quite hold it to three. 4 Forschner/Vicky. One 10" Fibrox chef. Two straight 6" boning with rosewood, one flexible, one stiff. And one Fibrox Forschner stiff boning knife with the swept back blade All 4 bought at a yard sale for a total of 8 bucks.

They sharpen easily, hold an edge moderately, as one would expect, and function surprisingly well for their intended purpose, and I use them often in spite of a fairly decent collection of Japanese knives (Nothing fancy like the rest of you guys...Tojiro gyuto , Kagayaki wa gyuto, Kanemasa honesuki, Tanaka gyuto, Yoshikane 240 hammered wa gyuto, couple of Shun Classic paring knives. None of which I bought new or paid anywhere NEAR retail.

Frugal doesn't come near to describing me. Parsimonious would be the closest. My name appears in the dictionary right beside Bargain hunter/Skinflint.
 
Forgot my honerable mention would be my VG10 Ikea chefs knife. I did t buy it, but at 50$ I would in a heartbeat
 
Once I've found an abandoned Victorinox rosewood cimitar neglected, abused (an obvious case of a res derelicta).
I took pity of it and it was my first serious project knife.
As it was clearly being abandoned, (and neglected etc.) I am far from wondering why the original owner didn't reclaim it.
I'm happy I could save it from further misuse.
 
-Victorinox serrated steak knives
-Fujiwara FKM petty
 
1. Robert Herder carbon paring knife. I think it was 6 Euro brand new. Insanely sharp.
2. Dexter Russell filleting knife I found stuck in a beam at an old abbattoir. I guess that's a find rather than a buy but it didn't cost much. Ran a steel over it and Bob's your uncle. Carbon of course.
3. ICEL Santuko. Can't remember how much it cost but wasn't a lot. Think I found it at a charity shop. Glad ICEL's been mentioned. I think it's the best make of affordable stainless kitchen knives.
 
Once I've found an abandoned Victorinox rosewood cimitar neglected, abused (an obvious case of a res derelicta).
I took pity of it and it was my first serious project knife.
As it was clearly being abandoned, (and neglected etc.) I am far from wondering why the original owner didn't reclaim it.
I'm happy I could save it from further misuse.

A sad, sad story but with a positive finish. Some people make me sick!
 
$26 calphalon katana 5" utility vg1
$25 shun sheepsfoot parer
$free tojiro dp santoku
 
+1 on the Pure Komachi bread knife. I got mine for about $10 on ebay. Not much to look at, but it cuts bread just fine.
 
pumbaa, that Calphalon utility has always made me wonder. They have a 7" slicer, or honesuki, or something (can't remember) that I always thought had great potential too. Too bad they don't just get them made in Japan.
 
11.011.05.jpg



When this Dojo knife was like $55 it was a great bargain (with blue #1 steel core) to have and still remains a favorite of mine to use but at $110 now I'd never buy it again.
 
Perhaps the same might be said of Tojiro DP 240 gyuto which was 60 bucks when I bought it and now commonly double that. Now that I think about it, this may be a knife that I did, in fact, buy new at retail, from Korin no less.
 
Forschner Fibrox 10" Chef's Knife, $40.00; Forschner Fibrox Bread Knife, $30.00; CCK 1303, $40.00. I hesitated to put the chef's knife on there, but that Forschner performs better than any big name German knife costing 3 or 4 times it's price. The steel may be crap, but it's thin, light, and sharpens up pretty nicely. I'm surprised I'm the first to mention the 1303.
 
Sorry Andrew, missed that one, you did beat me to it.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top