mostly different companies. Forgecraft was actually from the olde forge line owned by Washington Forge and went out of production in 1968. old hickory is owned by Ontario knife co. and is still made today. Chicago cutlery made a version at one time and I think that may have been under Lamson before the brand sold and moved production to China. Case cutlery made their version and Remington and Winchester made theirs. In the late sixties and early seventies most of the companies that made these types of knives had blanks made by OEM companies under licensing agreements and slapped their name on them. It is widely believed that most if not all of these were made 10xx steels of some type, more then likely 1095. In the case of Old hickory definitely, 1095. There is nothing wrong with the old vintage carbon steel knives made by the various brands. It comes down to what you like. I personally love the old forgecrafts because they take a wicked edge and have a really great profile. I like old hickory for the same reason. One isn't any better than the other.