For the Metallurgists?

Kitchen Knife Forums

Help Support Kitchen Knife Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Salty dog

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2011
Messages
2,326
Reaction score
55
Are brass fumes dangerous?

Hypothetical question? If one were to smoke, let's say......tobacco, out of a a 9mm brass shell casing, would you get cancer or something?
 
There are many brasses. You'd have to be more specific. Cancer isn't something I'd be worried about, particularly. I'm not a metallurgist, but I've edited more than my share of environmental toxicology grants.
 
I am not a metallurgist, however I smoke tobacco pipes often, and from my understanding brass is an alloy made from zinc and copper, and heating brass, depending on the brass, can release zinc oxide fumes which are pretty dangerous. I don't think a lighter is going to be hot enough to cause that to happen, but I'm not 100% sure. I would play it safe and avoid it.
 
It's only a temporary solution but it got me thinking........wondering.........dreaming.......ah, never mind.
 
I am not a metallurgist, however I smoke tobacco pipes often, and from my understanding brass is an alloy made from zinc and copper, and heating brass, depending on the brass, can release zinc oxide fumes which are pretty dangerous. I don't think a lighter is going to be hot enough to cause that to happen, but I'm not 100% sure. I would play it safe and avoid it.

The main problem is that may brasses include lead.
 
A friend of mine broke part of his delicate pipe. He noticed that a 9mm shell casing fit perfectly into the "hole". (Because they're laying around) drilled a hole in it and realized it worked pretty good except the metallic taste.
 
I wouldn't worry about it, unless thou do that for the next few years, and every day.
 
Brass isn't the issue of the cancer causing properties of what your friend is doing, but that's another lecture. Pure brass is not an issue since it's an inert metal to the human body unless it oxidizes with leather or other tanned materials. As longs as your friend cleans it properly then it won't be a problem. If he thinks the action is causing cancer or optical delusions then he needs to check what he's putting in the pipe.
 
If one was worried about cancer then one should vaporize his/her "tobacco".
 
If you worry about cancer, just quit smoking.
 
I don't think this would be much of an issue. The main problem is with the zinc in the brass and that is toxic, but mostly that's as a gas, which means the brass would have to be in a molten state above the melting temp of zinc about 1665f is when it turns to a gas.
thanks,
Del
 
If you vaporize you are not smoking.
Sorry BK, maybe I wasnt clear, but I was responding to the topic starter. :)

'Vaping' as its called here is a bit controversial in the NL as health agencies think health effects havent been properly researched yet.
 
Back
Top