Restaurant in midtown nyc? This Sunday?

So I'm taking my wife to see a show in nic on Sunday...it starts at1:00 and goes till like 3:30. Wanna go to an early dinner around 4-4:30 somewhere close in midtown

Budget is not a big deal but I ain't spending a few hundred at Le Bernardin. My wife likes plain food....meat potatoes etc...I'd even go to a pizzeria if it was really good....any suggestions....I'd spend say 100-150 for both of us....ryan

Keens
Doesn't fit your description of simple, but Junoon
Sakagura

Theater Row Café. A long time friend of mine owns it but I like the food there too. Great location for Broadway theater stuff.

How about Virgil's? Pongsri Thai is pretty good too.