Is @japanese _natural_whetstone a trustworthy seller?

[Miyamoto Musashi]

https://instagram.com/japanese_natural_whetstone?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=

This person seems legitimate to me but I wanted to ask if anyone here has ordered from them previously and whether they could share their experience. Funnily enough, I’m not looking for a natural stone but for the metal plate.

Thank you!

 

[Hassanbensober]

Never had an actual conversation with the person. I have bought a couple stones from the seller through yahoo japan auctions. The stones I bought are good quality stones and accurately described.

 

[refcast]

I ordered a steel flat plate from him and it was pretty darn flat too

 

[Dan-]

Ah he is s*i*o…

 

[Miyamoto Musashi]

I ordered a steel flat plate from him and it was pretty darn flat too

I can’t tell whether this is sarcastic or not.

If you did, was shipping reasonably priced and did it get to you within a reasonable timespan?

 

[refcast]

The flat plate comment was not supposed to be sarcastic but I neglected to write it better

I have this plate


I used a proxy though so shipping was probably lower through them, at least it should be. From Japan proxy

He has this precision flat plate I think you saw, that I thought to get for Kanna or checking flatness. For knives I don't really need it, but I got it to check knife edge profiles. I think checking by eye is faster though for me now. It is flatter than the atoma plate for example

He has a bunch of stuff on Yahoo auction. He does cater to woodworking and knife folks, and he has the lowest price on Tsushima, and price matches those.

He has a lot of slurry pictures with what looks like from a diamond plate. So I wouldn't be able to tell you if the stones self slurry or not. But I buy stones off pictures of the stone itself mostly, and go for matte stone textures, like flat or velvet paint. I think @ethompson might have experience with the seller but I'm not sure.

 

[Miyamoto Musashi]

The flat plate comment was not supposed to be sarcastic but I neglected to write it better

I have this plate


I used a proxy though so shipping was probably lower through them, at least it should be. From Japan proxy

He has this precision flat plate I think you saw, that I thought to get for Kanna or checking flatness. For knives I don't really need it, but I got it to check knife edge profiles. I think checking by eye is faster though for me now. It is flatter than the atoma plate for example

He has a bunch of stuff on Yahoo auction. He does cater to woodworking and knife folks, and he has the lowest price on Tsushima, and price matches those.

He has a lot of slurry pictures with what looks like from a diamond plate. So I wouldn't be able to tell you if the stones self slurry or not. But I buy stones off pictures of the stone itself mostly, and go for matte stone textures, like flat or velvet paint. I think @ethompson might have experience with the seller but I'm not sure.

Yeah this is exactly what I looking at as well. Plan to use it as a kanaban.

 

[simona]

I can give the URL if it's not treading on people's toes.

I think I bought a smaller stone from him last year - it did what it said on the packet. He is certainly a regular seller on the Japanese sites that I check on a near daily basis, mixing cheaper koppas with some more expensive stones as well as the occasional knife, powders and so forth.

 

[user 16756]

I've bought four stones from him; one from Yahoo JP and 3 direct.

Something to keep in mind is that you're not going to get quite the same enthusiasm to just discuss natural stones or the extensive testing notes you would get buying from some of the individuals around here, or at least I haven't gotten that sense. But, there's really nothing to complain about IMO

 

[KasumiJLA]

Never had an actual conversation with the person. I have bought a couple stones from the seller through yahoo japan auctions. The stones I bought are good quality stones and accurately described.

Same thing for me on yahoo auction. Never spoke to him directly but I heard some good and bad. Maybe I was juste lucky

 

[ReiHamono]

I should disclose that I’m friends with the seller.

He’s really great and accommodating. He has a website that you can order directly from linked on his IG