DrEriksson
Senior Member
Two big boys that are oh so sweet.
1. All depends on what you're used to.
2. A lot of factory edges aren't meant to be used as such. Just helpful for the end-user so he can put his own edge on it, with only a few strokes. A factory edge shouldn't be the object of any special veneration. Traditionally, Japanese blades used to come without an edge. The end-user was supposed to sharpen himself — or let the retailer do it for him, at his cost. With today's export this is no longer acceptable. So, there has to be an edge on it. Put on it with a few strokes by the youngest apprentice. A bit of buffering for deburring, and done!
Only some expensive knives and (semi)customs come with a decent edge. Even then it isn't necessarily the kind of edge you're looking for.
3. Don't use an edge with an inclusive angle of 12° with board contact and complain about the steel being chippy.
How does the yoshikane compare to the kobayashi? I have had a very similiar experience to you, takamura>kobayashi and now I am thinking of one, but might just get a koutetsu.Thanks to this thread I just got a Yoshikane, the first whoa for me tho is Takamura R2 210mm gyuto, then Kobayashi Kei
View attachment 163001
How does the yoshikane compare to the kobayashi? I have had a very similiar experience to you, takamura>kobayashi and now I am thinking of one, but might just get a koutetsu.
View attachment 200062
San Mai Damascus Gyuto by Alex Horn. Definitely the sharpest ootb knife I’ve encountered. Another pic and Alex’s own words from IG.
View attachment 200063View attachment 200064View attachment 200065View attachment 200066
Those are stunning knives. They look thin and sharp.View attachment 200062
San Mai Damascus Gyuto by Alex Horn. Definitely the sharpest ootb knife I’ve encountered. Another pic and Alex’s own words from IG.
View attachment 200063View attachment 200064View attachment 200065View attachment 200066
I'd give a try for Yoshikane, I like it more than both, Shibata would be very similar to Kobayashi in term of thinness and cutting feel, Yoshikane is a whole different story, it might not impress you at the first but it just keep growing on me in terms of general cutting feel and comfort in use.How does the yoshikane compare to the kobayashi? I have had a very similiar experience to you, takamura>kobayashi and now I am thinking of one, but might just get a koutetsu.
Enter your email address to join: