Hello!
Quick summary:
I am in the market for another splash and go coarse stone. I really like my Nano Hone 200, and I am wondering how it compares to the Suehiro debado ld-21 or md-20, Shapton Kuromaku 220, or Shapton Glass 220. I care most about how deep the scratches are when polishing bevels, how fast the stone dishes, how long the stone lasts (stone life/$), and maybe cutting speed.
Longer Explanation:
My first coarse stone was a Gesshin 220 pink brick. I generally liked that stone (well enough to use it until it got to ~1 mm in thickness), but I didn’t like how fast it dished or how it would leave very coarse and very deep scratches while thinning and polishing.
I got the Nano Hone 200 because I was running out of Gesshin 220, and I wanted a splash and go coarse stone that I could take on the go. After using the Nano Hone 200 for a while, I realized that I really like it, and it did not have the same issues as the Gesshin 220. It did not dish super quickly or leave super deep/coarse scratches while thinning or polishing. I am very happy with this stone.
After thinning and polishing several knives and sharpening numerous knives, I have 3-4 mm left, which seems fair, but I am realizing that I need to find a replacement soon because I don’t have that much stone left. While thinking about replacement, I thought that maybe a different coarse splash and go stone could offer the same performance and characteristics that I like about the Nano Hone 200 while offering a better value of stone life/thickness to $. I will happily repurchase the Nano Hone 200 if other stones do not offer the same properties, so I am hoping to learn how other stones compare to it in this thread. I am wondering how the Nano Hone 200 compares to the Suehiro Debado ld-21/md-20, Shapton Kuromaku 220, and the Shapton Glass 220. Also, if you have any other suggestions, I would love to hear them.
Quick summary:
I am in the market for another splash and go coarse stone. I really like my Nano Hone 200, and I am wondering how it compares to the Suehiro debado ld-21 or md-20, Shapton Kuromaku 220, or Shapton Glass 220. I care most about how deep the scratches are when polishing bevels, how fast the stone dishes, how long the stone lasts (stone life/$), and maybe cutting speed.
Longer Explanation:
My first coarse stone was a Gesshin 220 pink brick. I generally liked that stone (well enough to use it until it got to ~1 mm in thickness), but I didn’t like how fast it dished or how it would leave very coarse and very deep scratches while thinning and polishing.
I got the Nano Hone 200 because I was running out of Gesshin 220, and I wanted a splash and go coarse stone that I could take on the go. After using the Nano Hone 200 for a while, I realized that I really like it, and it did not have the same issues as the Gesshin 220. It did not dish super quickly or leave super deep/coarse scratches while thinning or polishing. I am very happy with this stone.
After thinning and polishing several knives and sharpening numerous knives, I have 3-4 mm left, which seems fair, but I am realizing that I need to find a replacement soon because I don’t have that much stone left. While thinking about replacement, I thought that maybe a different coarse splash and go stone could offer the same performance and characteristics that I like about the Nano Hone 200 while offering a better value of stone life/thickness to $. I will happily repurchase the Nano Hone 200 if other stones do not offer the same properties, so I am hoping to learn how other stones compare to it in this thread. I am wondering how the Nano Hone 200 compares to the Suehiro Debado ld-21/md-20, Shapton Kuromaku 220, and the Shapton Glass 220. Also, if you have any other suggestions, I would love to hear them.