Ripoff of Don Nguyen's designs?

Kitchen Knife Forums

Help Support Kitchen Knife Forums:

Zwiefel

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
3,266
Reaction score
4
Looks like someone is trying to copy Don:

https://www.instagram.com/p/BAXRWBSQLgQ/

Clearly not capable of his F-n-F though, I don't have much hope for the grind/heat treat either. If anyone wanted to leave a comment on instagram to this effect, I would not be personally offended. Or even if several people did....
 

bkultra

Staff member
Administrator
Global Moderators
Joined
Apr 4, 2011
Messages
3,868
Reaction score
539
Location
Chicago
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery
 

James

Senior Member
Joined
May 17, 2011
Messages
1,160
Reaction score
65
Looks like the guy has been trying different things to find his own style
 

Haburn

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2013
Messages
910
Reaction score
2
I know Joe, and he's a very nice guy but I do think his handles are too close to Nyugen's work.
 

alterwisser

Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2015
Messages
1,795
Reaction score
334
Unless someone has a patent/copyright/trademark or any other kind of protection on a design or anything like that there's not much one can do about this kind of stuff... Unfortunately!

About the Haburn vs Anderson debate: I don't think that handle style is so unique that any maker can claim it as his/her own. I've seen it on Bloodroot blades as well I think ... (Just my personal opinion!)
 

WillC

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2011
Messages
2,106
Reaction score
1
Dons is a very unique design, his own invention of form and aesthetic. I think of course its natural to take influence in ones development and its not always as straight forward to determine influence in general but this case its respectful to the maker to quote your source, i.e. "Nyugen -esc handle" It is then an honest homage and a stage in ones development, with full credit where it is due to the original. Thats how I would feel about it, can't speak for Don.
 

Zwiefel

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
3,266
Reaction score
4
Unless someone has a patent/copyright/trademark or any other kind of protection on a design or anything like that there's not much one can do about this kind of stuff... Unfortunately!

About the Haburn vs Anderson debate: I don't think that handle style is so unique that any maker can claim it as his/her own. I've seen it on Bloodroot blades as well I think ... (Just my personal opinion!)
Legally, correct. Socially? Incorrect.

Dons is a very unique design, his own invention of form and aesthetic. I think of course its natural to take influence in ones development and its not always as straight forward to determine influence in general but this case its respectful to the maker to quote your source, i.e. "Nyugen -esc handle" It is then an honest homage and a stage in ones development, with full credit where it is due to the original. Thats how I would feel about it, can't speak for Don.
Exactly my point. There's nothing wrong with learning from doing, and being inspired by the work of others...not a single person reaches any real level of achievement in any art w/o that...but you should list your sources, as they say in the academic world.
 

Adrian

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2015
Messages
254
Reaction score
1
Pretty tricky this don't you think? A knife is a flat bit of pointy metal stuck into a handle. They have been around for thousands of years. In that time you would expect just about every variation of handle (and blade) shape to have been made somewhere. Go into a museum and look at the evolution of medieval blades to present day. I suspect there is very little new under this particular ray of sun.
 

malexthekid

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
1,896
Reaction score
2
Personally i don't think the knife is a rip off of Don's work as opposed to just a different take on tapering a wa handle. Yes has similarities to Don but as for rip off, i think it some are seeing it that way because the want to "defend" Don's work.

.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

mikedtran

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2015
Messages
1,368
Reaction score
2
Personally i don't think the knife is a rip off of Don's work as opposed to just a different take on tapering a wa handle. Yes has similarities to Don but as for rip off, i think it some are seeing it that way because the want to "defend" Don's work.
I would be inclined to believe it is a copy of Don's handle as that is a very unique tapering. Additionally, since he deleted comments on that versus have a discussion about it, would leave me further to believe it was a copy of Don's.

Even the way he layered the Micarta is very reminiscent of Don's style.

That being said there is no comparison as far as attention to detail and execution though. Don tapers his full tangs to pull the weight blade forward and from the video that does not look to be the case with Penmans handle.

I agree with the general idea that borrowing design elements is ok with recognition. This also has no real negative impact on Don, actually might be giving him some additional press/reach =p
 

malexthekid

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
1,896
Reaction score
2
Maybe/maybe not. My impression is that the tapering of the tang and overall shape is what makes Don's handle what it is. This knife is either a really poor copy missing out on the key aspects. Or it really is just a modification of a wa.

As for deleting comments being a sign of guilt... why should he have to leave accusations out in the public that are unfounded themselves. He doesn't need to engage with people, who in reality would not change their mind even if he did.
 

ecchef

Staff member
Founding Member
Global Moderators
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2011
Messages
5,857
Reaction score
143
Location
MCAS Miramar
Personally i don't think the knife is a rip off of Don's work as opposed to just a different take on tapering a wa handle. Yes has similarities to Don but as for rip off, i think it some are seeing it that way because the want to "defend" Don's work.
I don't buy that. To begin with, it has none of the characteristics of a "wa" handle; you would have been more accurate to compare it with a Forgecraft or even an Ealy. The faceting is identical to Don's work as is the planar transition and geometry. Yeah, it's got a few (a lot) more pins and maybe there is no distal taper, but come on...it's an obvious copy.
 
Last edited:

malexthekid

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
1,896
Reaction score
2
I don't buy that. To begin with, it has none of the characteristics of a "wa" handle; you would have been more accurate to compare it with a Forgecraft or even an Ealy. The faceting is identical to Don's work as is the planar transition and geometry. Yeah, it's got a few (a lot) more pins and maybe there is no distal taper, but come on...it's an obvious copy.
Says you. I'll give the guy the benefit of the doubt.
 

malexthekid

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
1,896
Reaction score
2
I don't even know why i am arguing for this guy. I don't even like his work.

But let's agree to disagree. There are enough similarities to make it potential but there is enough differences to suggest it may just be a natural progression of his. But we will never know the truth.
 

Matus

Staff member
Global Moderators
Hobbyist Craftsman
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2013
Messages
7,708
Reaction score
1,518
Location
Germany
Since I do not know the guy in question and neither his work, I would not be all so jumpy. Check out his gallery - there is ONE knife with such a handle design - it is apparent that he offers quite different handles. And I have no idea whether it is a design ispired by someone else's work or not.

So, I am sorry, but I am not ready to throw that bag of poo just yet.

P.S. Indeed not cheap, but offers steels I have not seen from anyone else. So, actually, thanks for the link :D:angel2:
 

MAS4T0

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2013
Messages
924
Reaction score
16
I'd give the guy the benefit of the doubt.

Maybe he didn't realise that it was a unique design created by Don?
Or maybe he reached the same point independently?

The world is a big place and I wouldn't say that it was impossible that he came to that design on his own (as unlikely as that may be).

I agree that it is bad form if it is a copy and no credit was given. Hopefully if that is the case (and he sees this thread) he'll add a credit to Don.
 

Asteger

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
2,048
Reaction score
10
Pricey knives. I was just thinking if this maker had made buddies here, tried to reg as a vendor, etc, first - not sure exactly what the process is - he wouldn't have met such scepticism, and scepticism which could be unfair. I also had a quick look at the site and noticed just one handle with that distinctive kind of Nguyen shape. (Maybe he got a request for this design and just took a pic?)

On the other hand, the handle in question and the general look of his knives are a bit garish. I only know a bit about Nguyen's stuff and it's distinctive but not my cup of tea, and so if I were to copy designs I wouldn't have gone for these.
 

mikedtran

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2015
Messages
1,368
Reaction score
2
Both great points above.

Seems like two very likely scenarios that either he didn't realize it was a unique design or/and he was asked by a client to make a handle based on pictures of Don's.

Most interesting thing this thread brings up for me is how unique Don's design is, so much so that a decent number of people instantly think of Don when they see a handle like that.

Also makes you think, whoever came up with the first octagonal handle or the first d-handle isn't being credited now =p
 

WildBoar

Home cook, knife accumulator
Founding Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2011
Messages
4,627
Reaction score
736
Location
NoVa (US)
I agree. I've seen hundreds of knives where the wa-handles are not credited as being 'a la ______'. Obviously someone came up with it initially... Same for the generic western handles.

Next up may be claiming exclusivity on blade shapes/ profiles.
 

MAS4T0

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2013
Messages
924
Reaction score
16
Also makes you think, whoever came up with the first octagonal handle or the first d-handle isn't being credited now =p
I always assumed that D handles were created by this dude and that their name and shape was an homage to their creator. :pirate1:

I'm not sure about Octagonal handles though. :scratchhead:

 

Zwiefel

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2012
Messages
3,266
Reaction score
4
I agree. I've seen hundreds of knives where the wa-handles are not credited as being 'a la ______'. Obviously someone came up with it initially... Same for the generic western handles.

Next up may be claiming exclusivity on blade shapes/ profiles.
In 100 years if Don's handles are the standard...sure, that would be analogous.
 

CrisAnderson27

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
467
Reaction score
4
I spoke to Stephen on his Instagram page. He admitted that it was 'inspired' by Don, but then proceeded to point out one or two differences that were supposed to make it original somehow. This tells me that it was purposeful, not an accident (and come on, that's a pretty far fetched 'design' to come up with out of the blue, particularly considering his other handle shapes). In addition, a number of other people commented the same thing. Deleting those comments, to me...was the part that made it truly something I personally wouldn't appreciate. Another guy has been copying Don's handles as well. His name is Joe Edson (he's a great guy) and he mostly makes straight razors. The difference is, he fully admitted it, as well as admitting that he did it out of complete and total respect for Don's work. The posts are still public on his Instagram page...rather than being hidden to avoid notice. Similar actions, two different responses from the people who did it, and a completely different reaction from people who stood up and pointed it out.

The thing about this issue is that makers who come up with unique designs that are both beautiful and functional are rare. Even rarer are those that come up with unique designs that are exceedingly beautiful and functional. If we don't back them as a community, there's very little incentive for them to do so outside of their own will. I can tell you that as an artist/sculptor of sorts, that will is strong...but if someone were copying my art, and the community that I made it for didn't stand up for my efforts in the face of pretty blatant plagiarism...I would be more than a little saddened.

It would be a lot different folks, if he had just modified a 'wa' handle. Don's handle isn't an octagonal/wa handle in the first place...it's not even freaking close. It's more of a skewed hexagonal/multi-tapered diamond with purposeful facets. It is/was completely unique in the kitchen knife world. Think about Bob Loveless. There's a MILLION knife makers out there copying his design. But guess what the design is called? A Loveless drop point. I think Don's design is unique enough to warrant at MINIMUM the respect of calling your copy of his work by his name in a public format. 'Here is my 240mm chef's knife with a Don Nguyen style/inspired handle'...and not just once, either. Every single time you make one.

Doesn't seem so hard at all to me.
 

AllanP

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2014
Messages
185
Reaction score
1
I don't know why he was deleting comments about it, that's the weird part

maybe he didn't want bad publicity or drama on his Instagram page
 

WildBoar

Home cook, knife accumulator
Founding Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2011
Messages
4,627
Reaction score
736
Location
NoVa (US)
Cris, thanks for your perspective.
 

MAS4T0

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2013
Messages
924
Reaction score
16
Thanks for clearing that up Chris.

In that case, I agree, it was a low move. I don't see deleting negative comments as a major issue (as it is his page) but he should certainly have added a reference to Don at this point.

I was in no way defending straight up plagiarism, but I'd rather assume the best and be proven wrong (as is the case here) than assume the worst.
 
Top