I’ve tried classic wa handles and full integral bolsters before, but have never held or used a semi-integral knife. Who in your mind does the best semi-integral bolsters whether it’s for cosmetic, functional, or ergonomic reasons?
Best semi-integrals in the game
- Thread starter Blumbo
- Start date
Help Support Kitchen Knife Forums:
OkayMode
I am the pig Daveb's mama was talking about
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2023
- Messages
- 1,258
- Reaction score
- 3,447
I really like my Joel Black - it’s rustic but feels great.
Simon Maillet did a cool one recently but wasn’t keen when I requested it as a custom order - apparently they are not fun to make.
Simon Maillet did a cool one recently but wasn’t keen when I requested it as a custom order - apparently they are not fun to make.
The Simon mallet semi-integral is what got me interested in the first place! The smooth taper relative to traditional integrals is so satisfying!!
SylvainM
KKF Supporting Craftsman
Hi there,
Did one recently that I posted on the forum a few weeks ago, in case you wanna have a look at it.
As you say, it's not always fun to do those things (even worst with the damascus I'd say as you have to handle the pattern reveal versus the fitting) but well, sometimes they turn out great
https://www.kitchenknifeforums.com/threads/should-i-call-this-a-quarter-integral-bolster.70491
For your viewing pleasure
Did one recently that I posted on the forum a few weeks ago, in case you wanna have a look at it.
As you say, it's not always fun to do those things (even worst with the damascus I'd say as you have to handle the pattern reveal versus the fitting) but well, sometimes they turn out great
https://www.kitchenknifeforums.com/threads/should-i-call-this-a-quarter-integral-bolster.70491
For your viewing pleasure
If it wasn’t for the profile the Simon Maillet would have never left my house
Such a smooth taper
Leszek Sikon and Henry Hyde have some great semi-integrals. I'll grab some pics later when I get home for a reference.
Hi there,
Did one recently that I posted on the forum a few weeks ago, in case you wanna have a look at it.
As you say, it's not always fun to do those things (even worst with the damascus I'd say as you have to handle the pattern reveal versus the fitting) but well, sometimes they turn out great
https://www.kitchenknifeforums.com/threads/should-i-call-this-a-quarter-integral-bolster.70491
For your viewing pleasure
This is really pretty and precise looking work! I can't begin to imagine how much time and effort went into it. My one concern is where the most comfortable spot to pinch it would be since the neck is a little longer.
I generally prefer full integral or traditional wa handles, but this semi-integral from Henry Hyde is super comfortable and does a good job balancing a large blade.
Isasmedjan semi-integrals are top tier. I’ve handled a few of them, and even sold one a while back that I still regret. Only western I regret letting go. The Kurouchi one is the gem I’m referring to. Others were nice also.
- Joined
- Aug 27, 2019
- Messages
- 3,617
- Reaction score
- 7,704
+1 isasmedjan
My Hyde and Leszek Sikon
Maybe Leszek's is a true integral and not a semi? Any experts care to weigh in?
Maybe Leszek's is a true integral and not a semi? Any experts care to weigh in?
Last edited:
Hockey3081
Senior Member
There appears to be nothing semi about that Sikon. Both are beauties.
Not trying to divert the thread too much, but the variance between handle material and tang would be the indicator of a semi-integral?
I guess I was assuming a true integral had to be full tang and anything that wasn't full tang, was semi
I guess I was assuming a true integral had to be full tang and anything that wasn't full tang, was semi
In my mind, I feel like integral refers to the bolster, where tang is something separate
-Integral:
Full: - metal is flush with wood
Semi: - metal is not flush with wood and has an heirloom-like fit
None: - metal is continuous with tang at similar thickness
-Tang:
Full: visible from top and bottom, usually with rivets
Hidden: not visible as metal is within handle
I assume you could have any combination of integration and tang type, but typically we see full integral with full tang, full integral with hidden tang, and no integral with hidden tang and semis are typically hidden as well
-Integral:
Full: - metal is flush with wood
Semi: - metal is not flush with wood and has an heirloom-like fit
None: - metal is continuous with tang at similar thickness
-Tang:
Full: visible from top and bottom, usually with rivets
Hidden: not visible as metal is within handle
I assume you could have any combination of integration and tang type, but typically we see full integral with full tang, full integral with hidden tang, and no integral with hidden tang and semis are typically hidden as well
Yoshi
Shindo Maniac
Is there any advantage/disadvantage with integrated/semi?
For me it’s all about feel. Biggest advantage is the comfort in a pinch grip. I find the spine of thin knives digs in to my finger in a pinch grip after a while of use. A semi integral make it suuuper comfortable and much more robust in your hand. It just feels more ergonomic and comfortable I guess is what I’m trying to say.
Can’t wait for Rob to be back in the workshop
I didn’t know he was out of it, is he ok? Or just busy with other things?
OkayMode
I am the pig Daveb's mama was talking about
- Joined
- Jan 23, 2023
- Messages
- 1,258
- Reaction score
- 3,447
He’s had to move about a little bit and is currently working on a house build. He’s temporarily stopped production until he’s got a long term workshop site up and running.
Ah I see, thank you.
Probably unpopular. But semi and full integrals are not good, I like a slight forward weight. The semi’s create a dead spot for me because of my tendency to have distal taper as well. They are also more expensive. 4-5mm seems to be my sweet spot out the handle. Standard wa has withstood the test of time with me. I love the drop down from handle to blade as it provides me with a good pinch.
I’d probably just get one super nice one and leave it at that. Like that Oosik handle one from HF. He makes some very clean ones. But then again, there are a ton of beautiful integrals out there
I’d probably just get one super nice one and leave it at that. Like that Oosik handle one from HF. He makes some very clean ones. But then again, there are a ton of beautiful integrals out there
Hockey3081
Senior Member
Integral refers to integral bolster. i.e. the bolster is integrated into the steel and is the transition between the blade and the rest of the handle material.
Curious if anyone has tried Fellipi’s semi integrals or knives in general - have been curious about getting a custom.
A spine shot from his insta that scratches an itch.
A spine shot from his insta that scratches an itch.
I have a full integral for sale if interested
- Joined
- Dec 15, 2011
- Messages
- 11,258
- Reaction score
- 7,546
This makes me kinda want to try another Mazaki
