Help! I need a mortar and pestle

[boomchakabowwow]

I don’t even know where to start.

Cast iron, stone, ceramic? I’ve owned some sucky ones that where better at holding down papers in the wind. I want to revisit crushing spices and stuff.

Thanks. Any suggestions?

 

[McMan]

This one:
https://importfood.com/index.php?option=com_zoo&task=item&item_id=3639&Itemid=195

 

[HRC_64]

The best one i've used for spices (specifically) is this style,

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00X3KTPPA/?tag=skimlinks_replacement-20

 

[chinacats]

Imo you need 2...a small one for spices and a large one for making guac, etc. They should be heavy, deep enough and not too steep.

 

[boomchakabowwow]

This one:
https://importfood.com/index.php?option=com_zoo&task=item&item_id=3639&Itemid=195

Ugh. Sold out on the bigger ones.

 

[Anton]

Imo you need 2...a small one for spices and a large one for making guac, etc. They should be heavy, deep enough and not too steep.

Yup

 

[Paraffin]

Imo you need 2...a small one for spices and a large one for making guac, etc. They should be heavy, deep enough and not too steep.

Double yup (see, who needs a "Like" button)

I have a small white porcelain one for grinding small stuff like saffron threads, and a larger rough white porcelain one for large batches of homemade curry spices, thai spices, etc. Don't know the brands, we've had them a long time.

I've wanted to replace the larger one with a granite version for while. Not that the current one isn't doing the job, I've just always heard that granite is ideal. I haven't seen one I'd want yet, or that's in stock. Cole & Mason makes some nice-looking ones, but the larger size is hard to find, and there is some user feedback about the pestle breaking, because it's shaped with a narrow neck.

 

[buffhr]

I just use an Ikea one, cheap and does the job just fine and is "double sided" check it out easier then to explain , shallow side for spices deep side for everything else.

 

[Mucho Bocho]

I thought we settled this question years ago ChefSofi Mortar and Pestle Set - Unpolished Heavy Granite for Enhanced Performance and Organic Appearance - INCLUDED: Anti-Scratch Protector + Italian Recipes EBook - 6 Inch, 2 Cup-Capacity https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01HXWT40E/?tag=skimlinks_replacement-20

 

[btbyrd]

I use one of the larger ones (but not the largest one) from Import Thai Food. It's great, and deserves the positive press it's gotten. A shame they're sold out of all but the smallest right now.

 

[gunswanted]

I just use an Ikea one, cheap and does the job just fine and is "double sided" check it out easier then to explain , shallow side for spices deep side for everything else.

Same here. I went to ikea the first time in years and this was a score for me. Mine works great for mojito mint! I think it was 16$

 

[jackslimpson]

https://www.williams-sonoma.com/products/marble-mortar-and-pestle/?pkey=cmortars-pestles&isx=0.0.985

I've had this one for years. It's great. I'd try to snag it on sale, though.

Cheers,

Jack

 

[Ochazuke]

Even if you’ve already bought other mortar and pestles, I highly recommend a suribachi. They may not grind as quickly as the western variety in my experience, but they do a marvelous job at flavor extraction.

I couldn’t tell you the science behind it- it may be purely subjective, but nevertheless I feel like I get more flavor out of suribachi than traditional mortar and pestle.

 

[Leifer]

The larger all-stone mortar and pestles.... from the south orient or from Central America do need to be "broken-in" right ?
Typical method is to grind a couple of batches of raw uncooked rice... to eliminate any "first grind grit".

 

[boomchakabowwow]

I finally bought the smaller Cole and Mason.

I think you all are right; now I need a big one! I think mine is too small for pesto. Maybe in batches I could pull it off.

Mine is pretty good at bashing spices.

 

[pleue]

I'm a big fan of the thai style granite ones (polished, no grit like the central american ones) and a suribashi. If you're processing big batches, the preethi eco plus does a good job on spices/chutneys/etc.

 

[rstl87]

I finally bought the smaller Cole and Mason.

I think you all are right; now I need a big one! I think mine is too small for pesto. Maybe in batches I could pull it off.

Mine is pretty good at bashing spices.

I also have the Cole and Mason. Agreed it is great for spices. I have tried making curry paste and pesto in it and it needs to be done in batches but at least it's not too porous so it's quite easy to clean out afterwards.

 

[DitmasPork]

Really depends on what you need it for, as well as personal aesthetic preferences—there are quite a range, frame the classic French white marble to the Laotian/Thai clay Kruk. I don't believe there are perfect or bad mortar and pestles, but rather inappropriate ones for specific tasks,

Here are my mortar and pestles. Of which the most used are the $14, three-decade-old Thai granite (bottom left), great for grinding spices, pulverizing alliums into a paste; also well used is the $11 Japanese ceramic suribachi and surikogi, great for goma-ae, vinaigrette, pesto.

However, when making larger amounts, or on a deadline, I'll use my Krups coffee grinder, or Vita-Prep 3.