A tough decision to make

Kitchen Knife Forums

Help Support Kitchen Knife Forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
misscomunacation somewhere? I Have to wate for a new appointment, the person that I need to talk to had an out of town emergency. Just wish someone from H.R. would have called me.
 
Or you can live in Jersey City which I love and is a lot cheaper and 2400 will get you something nice is so close to the city via path it's like living in the city anyway...
 
Unfortunately, There is nothing "affordable" left which allows a basic standard of living accustomed to in other parts of the country. I moved out in '11 after 8 years. That being said, if you have not tried it and you have the opportunity you must - I really think this is the one city that has the most way about it, in other words, there is always a way and in my experience the reward can be great.
 
Living in the city is crazy expensive. $2500 a month will not get you very far unless you dont mind having a roommate ;) Best bet is to look uptown like upper east side or even higher on the west side like Harlem or Washington Heights. Lower East side can be a hit or miss and same with Alphabet City. Yuor other option is to look to the outer boroughs or NJ.

My advice is simple, no matter what industry you are in, having a high profile gig on your resume is never a bad thing. You can always use that to parlay that to something bigger in the future if you dont end up liking it. Not knowing where you are in your career or your financial health (not to be confused with financial wealth) its a tough call for anyone to advise you on a career move.
 
considering you have enough skills to get hired on to per se straight to soux chef i would think you should be plenty qualified to just own and operate your own establishment. unless you see some finacial backing possibilites happening through your time at per se, why bother? besides youre already 39 years old,which is like a 82 in chef years. what was keller doing when he was 39? learning under other people, or making his own mark?
 
misscomunacation somewhere? I Have to wate for a new appointment, the person that I need to talk to had an out of town emergency. Just wish someone from H.R. would have called me.

I'm just a young line cook & I don't know you, so my opinion doesn't matter much but --

I'd pass on Per Se

Working for TK is obviously an amazing resume builder and opens a lot of doors, but at this stage in your career how much does that really impact you? It sounds like you have experience being a CDC or exec. chef for quite some time. If Per Se is willing to consider you as a sous chef then you know a little bit about what you're doing, right? Unless you feel extremely motivated by their cuisine/level of fine dining and want to really spend some time playing the whole Michelin game (and be in NYC) - why do it?

I asked someone I knew to describe what it was like for them to work at Per Se, he responded w/ one word: "sterile". I have never seen their kitchen but it seems like they have a massive brigade - and that you're having to jump through so many hoops and go thru all this red tape to even find what your possible salary might be -- or if you even have the job -- says a whole lot about how they are as a company IMO. Not to say that they'd treat you bad, but this is a massive restaurant group and you'd just be another cog in the machine.

At your stage I would rather take a job where I could have a much more personal connection with my employer, more creative control over my menu and kitchen staff, and hell yes, more money too.

Just my two cents.

Best of luck with it all
 
considering you have enough skills to get hired on to per se straight to soux chef i would think you should be plenty qualified to just own and operate your own establishment. unless you see some finacial backing possibilites happening through your time at per se, why bother? besides youre already 39 years old,which is like a 82 in chef years. what was keller doing when he was 39? learning under other people, or making his own mark?

I opened a place a few years ago, last year my "partner " F'ed me pretty good, then god saw it fit to destroy the place via hurricane Sandy (thank you Lord), oh wait he hit me pretty hard with that storm too???
Anyway for "right now" in my life I don't necessarily want the #1 spot, and I definitely don't want to own anything or buy. A scene change and the chance to actually learn something new has its appeal.
 
I'm just a young line cook & I don't know you, so my opinion doesn't matter much but --

I'd pass on Per Se

Working for TK is obviously an amazing resume builder and opens a lot of doors, but at this stage in your career how much does that really impact you? It sounds like you have experience being a CDC or exec. chef for quite some time. If Per Se is willing to consider you as a sous chef then you know a little bit about what you're doing, right? Unless you feel extremely motivated by their cuisine/level of fine dining and want to really spend some time playing the whole Michelin game (and be in NYC) - why do it?

I asked someone I knew to describe what it was like for them to work at Per Se, he responded w/ one word: "sterile". I have never seen their kitchen but it seems like they have a massive brigade - and that you're having to jump through so many hoops and go thru all this red tape to even find what your possible salary might be -- or if you even have the job -- says a whole lot about how they are as a company IMO. Not to say that they'd treat you bad, but this is a massive restaurant group and you'd just be another cog in the machine.

At your stage I would rather take a job where I could have a much more personal connection with my employer, more creative control over my menu and kitchen staff, and hell yes, more money too.

Just my two cents.

Best of luck with it all

Everything you are saying sounds right there is right to me, sterile is a pretty good word.

I would rather take a job where I could have a much more personal connection with my employer,
I'm trying to avoid that actually right now.
 
And this might be the sexiest kitchen in the country right?
If you don't work there, I will be upset. That is yes indeedy the sexiest kitchen I have ever seen. The iconic "blue aprons".
 
However this could also be good, I took a screenshot of my email because I know you guys are going to start thinking im making all of this Sh1+ up LOL
aa192b3be0f460a3930c44107ed2410b.jpg
 
LOL! The plot thickens! Ramsey is a no doubt a super talented guy, but how could you ever work for the guy who was the original "knuckle head" in one of my favorite media center threads?
 
What a beaut! I'd almost vote for Ramsay just because it would set you apart in other resume's. How could you not notice that if you were a recruiter?
 
If you go with Ramsey you have to promise that you will smack him in the name of 3500 KKF members if you ever see him doing that stupid thing with a steel on his knife... ;)

In any case, I am glad to see that you have options. And your wish for your Dad to be around in times like this really made me think about my parents and how grateful I am that they are still around, even if they are 10,000 miles away. Thanks for that!

Stefan
 
Colin:

I can't stand in for your Dad, but I have kids your age and can tell you what I would tell them.

Money is not the most important thing in life. You are still young, with a long career ahead of you. An investment in the future which will open doors for you is something to seriously consider.

But in the end, kid, you have to go with your heart.

In any case, after the rough times you have had, I am really happy to see you with some attractive options.

Best wishes,

Keith
 
However this could also be good, I took a screenshot of my email because I know you guys are going to start thinking im making all of this Sh1+ up LOL
aa192b3be0f460a3930c44107ed2410b.jpg

I figure you might have seen this during your research, but just in case:

http://eater.com/archives/2013/10/03/how-did-gordon-ramsay-at-the-london-lose-its-michelin-stars.php

- Went from 2 stars to zero
- No exec chef (at least they didn't for the last few months)
- Gordon Ramsay is just a name, no longer a part of the restaurant
 
I wouldn't be surprised if Ramsey pulls his name from there. Most times the lessee has to keep up to the name, and most contracts have how that is satisfied. Losing 2 stars would def. be a deal breaker.

On the other side gratz on the job offer.
 
I meant to weigh in on this a while back, but its been busy over here. There has been a lot of good discussion in this thread, so i'm not sure how much this will add. Being a former culinary professional who still finds himself very much attached to the cooking world, i've found that my perspective has changed a lot on this kind of issue over the last few years. When i was cooking, fine dining was the only thing i cared about... it was about being the best, working with the best, and pushing yourself to the limit. At that point, my job was a job of passion, but with no real foresight to the future. Its hard to make enough to get by doing that kind of work, and unless you are really truly great at what you do, have great luck, and are prepared to sacrifice quality of life in favor of "the life", its hard to justify that lifestyle for long periods of time. Thats not to say i dont love and miss that part of the world, but it is to say that i understand what it takes to be able to live now better than i did before (have good insurance, savings, planning for the future, etc.).

If you are the guy who wants to be the best and push yourself, understanding that it will be at the cost of all else, then by all means take the TK job or any other job like that. It will be hard work, but its hard to get to the top without working with people like that... the way they work and the way they see things is just different... for those of you who have worked with guys like that, you know what i mean.

However, if you are starting to value your quality of life, want savings, planning for the future, etc., i would take another job. Maybe the Long Island thing or maybe something else. I have a lot of friends who work in corporate dining (some of which is more fine dining that others). That seems to be the kind of job i would want if i wanted quality of life and the ability to plan for my future well. I'm not saying take a job at sodexo (please dont... its like selling your soul to the devil), but companies like LEYE, Hillstone, Nobu, Wolfgang Puck (especially his hotel restaurants), etc., can do better for you in the long run. You need to be ok with corporate shenannigans, but its a smart long term move. You can always play around with fine dining anyways... its not like we all dont have friends who work at other restaurants... If i miss things, i can call up a number of people and get myself back in a fun kitchen for a day if i want... i'm sure you can do the same.

Oh... and skip the ramsey job.
 
Thanks John, to be honest I know exactly what you're saying and the whole reason I'm contemplating going to work in the city is that I have no real "quality of life" right now and I don't think I want one any time soon. I left a long term well paying job for what was supposed to be an "improvement" in my quality of life, mind you I made this decision under my ex-wife's pressure. Well most of you know that whole thing didn't work out so well. So after all of that, then the Hurricane and that accident I was just glad to finally get back to work last summer. However it's a crap job so anything is an improvement both and quality-of-life (work) and pay (hopefully).
 
Colin I wish the best to you whatever path you take.Many people have mixed feelings about Unions,which I can understand.Several times I was offered management position,but I had many yrs. in the Union,besides my job was that of working manager.Plus I had Ice Carving accounts with other Hotels which kept me busy & paid per sculpture was quite a bit more money than my Union scale pay.

I do not know about Unions on the mainland,here many Hotels still have.I don't know of any private reasturant with.I agree that cooks are underpaid.Janice was a registered Nurse made quite a bit more per hour than I did putting out Banquets.
 
I read this whole thread. I pondered. Im 10 years younger than you. I try to go for hotshot places over places which pay better because I know I wont be the best and I will learn. Now, I live in a totally different part of the country than you do. Managed to save up $10k and put a downpayment on a fixed up 2200sqft house across the street from a well cared for park. House payments are $715/ month. I dont make much ($12/hr) and I typically dont even get 40 hours a week anymore because its cheaper for the employer to run everyone just under. I make enough to cover all expenses and take care of my wife and kid and buy a new knife here and there.

Youre talking about paying $10k just to move somewhere. Youre looking at having $3k a month at least in expenses for a safe, clean life. In 10 years I can guarantee you that you will not be as motivated to get up and do the loco kitchen life thing as you are now.

I cant say which one is better, or which one you will regret or love. I would like to encourage you to start thinking about quality of life after you turn 50. What if you get too salty and wont be able to work anymore? Where will you live? How will you pay for things?

Ok...ok. I think that from a purely economical stance Id go with Long Island. Cheaper living costs, opportunity to shine and be your staffs Thomas Keller, opportunity to stash up some money and buy a house somewhere on the west coast where things are awesome and a lot quieter than the east side. Youre not gonna be a young buck forever and in 20 years your health wont care about how many cool people you worked for.

Hope I didnt come off too sharp. I wish you the best man. Make a 10 year plan and see which restaurant fits it better. Cheers mate!
 
Hope I didnt come off too sharp. I wish you the best man. Make a 10 year plan and see which restaurant fits it better. Cheers mate!

Not at all that's why I started this thread, be because I have this conflict in my mind. Every and any points of view/ insight is welcome, it helps me sort things out, gives me a broader perspective.
Thank you
 
One thing that is starting to sink in is that I think "most cooks" go to work for a guy like Keller to gain the experience, knowledge, and " the name" on a resume. They do this whit the hopes to obtain a better job (in pay and title), or to open their own place.
After reading this thread and the other one that's going on right now I'm starting to think:
I take the job with Keller to achieve what? I have a job looking me in the face that offering over 100k a year, this is obviously the upper tier of what just about any chef expect to make without owning his own place. I guess all my years spent on long island have built me a resume and reputation that allows me to get these upper tier job (on Long Island). The city would be a new start, but what do I expect to achieve from that new start? I think with all that has happened to me the past two years I might just be trying to "run away" from my " old life" rather then make the best of what I've got, and maybe in perspective might not really be that bad at all?
 
I am about your age (37) and though by this point in a career the skills/confidence/ability to do the job are there in spades, we are no longer young in this industry. I fully understand the desire to start fresh and especially with an exciting opportunity like per se, but personally moving down to a sous position (even senior, whatever that is) is going the wrong way. I am sure that there is room for advancement because the head guys in the kitchen gain their experience and go on to bigger and better things, Jonathan Benno/Corey Lee, but it is also a question of how long are you willing to wait. Maybe by the time you are 45 you have moved up the rungs, but then what. I can't see myself physically being able to cook past fifty and I am in shape, the job is just to hard on the mind and body. Sorry if I come off as negative but just wanted to throw my dice into the party. Good Luck but by the sounds of your last post it seems like you have made up your mind anyway.

laurie
 
One thing that is starting to sink in is that I think "most cooks" go to work for a guy like Keller to gain the experience, knowledge, and " the name" on a resume. They do this whit the hopes to obtain a better job (in pay and title), or to open their own place.
After reading this thread and the other one that's going on right now I'm starting to think:
I take the job with Keller to achieve what? I have a job looking me in the face that offering over 100k a year, this is obviously the upper tier of what just about any chef expect to make without owning his own place. I guess all my years spent on long island have built me a resume and reputation that allows me to get these upper tier job (on Long Island). The city would be a new start, but what do I expect to achieve from that new start? I think with all that has happened to me the past two years I might just be trying to "run away" from my " old life" rather then make the best of what I've got, and maybe in perspective might not really be that bad at all?

I think you're drawing the right conclusion. There's an old saying: "Better to be a big fish in a small pond than a small fish in a big one. Good luck either way.
 
Ok it done.
Looks like I'll be staying on Long Island as the Executive chef at the Shinacock Hills club.
 
Back
Top