I am wondering if people would be interested in 15n20 steel blades for the kitchen. It is most often used as the "shiney" steel in damascus and not too often used in blades I am guessing because it cannot be found in thicker sections than about .10 inches and usually as thin as .065. It is typically used as a bandsaw blade in saw mills. As far as composition it is basically 1075 with 2 percent nickle. Any thoughts?
15n20 as blade steel
- Thread starter JMJones
- Start date
Help Support Kitchen Knife Forums:
Aldo carries some thick enough to use as a kitchen knife. I have seen some close to 1/8 inch somewhere, but that is as thick as I have run across. Of course, the big question is what benefit will you get out of what would essentially be a tougher 1075 kitchen knife? There are people who would love to find some 1/4 stock to try a tough high quality nickel bearing steel on bushcraft knives, choppers and such without the quirks of real L6, but it is apparently nowhere to be found.
Eamon Burke
Banned
- Joined
- Mar 5, 2011
- Messages
- 4,931
- Reaction score
- 13
Why are you looking for thick slabs for kitchen knives?
I think the bennefit is that it is a tool grade high carbon steel that is available in nice thin stock for a very reasonable price. Finding anything besides stainless in 3/32 is tough. I know Aldo has some thin W2, I have some from him, but is is pretty expensive per pound compared to 15n20 because he needs to have it re rolled thinner.
To clarifty, I dont think many other, non kitchen knife makers use stock that is so thin. That is why I am wondering if it would be a good kitchen knife steel because it is already so thin.
Daniel Fairly
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2011
- Messages
- 52
- Reaction score
- 0
15n20 is an outstanding steel for kitchen knives. It is like 1075 but with nickel and other elements added for toughness. 15n20 combines good edge holding and toughness, you can't go wrong as long as you can find the size you want. I think if it were common in thicker sizes it would be used more often.
tgraypots
Senior Member
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2011
- Messages
- 537
- Reaction score
- 0
JMJones, I'm sorry I didn't follow up on your question. I never got a message.....
I have not tried any more 15n20 in a while, but hope to soon. I'm not sure why the residual curve stayed. I tempered the blades while c-clamped to angle iron at 375F, but no luck there. Even over-shimmed to compensate. I have another in the works though, and we'll see how it goes.
I have not tried any more 15n20 in a while, but hope to soon. I'm not sure why the residual curve stayed. I tempered the blades while c-clamped to angle iron at 375F, but no luck there. Even over-shimmed to compensate. I have another in the works though, and we'll see how it goes.
Andy, I think that a number of people would like to use 15N20, but you just can't get it thick enough and most people don't have the gear to mash it together. Like I said before, I think it would be great for hard use knives like L6, but a LOT easier to mess with.
Eamon Burke
Banned
- Joined
- Mar 5, 2011
- Messages
- 4,931
- Reaction score
- 13
How thick is the stock typically? It's usually hard to find steel thin enough for kitchen knives.
Depends on what one calls kitchen knife steel.
Mike Davis
Senior Member
- Joined
- May 2, 2011
- Messages
- 1,921
- Reaction score
- 0
I personally like to use 15N20. It is pretty damn tough, the nickel helps a tiny bit with corrosion, It hardens quite well, and is this...That means less expense in thinning it. When hardened it takes quite a wicked edge and seems to hold it quite well...Just my 2 cents on this.
Eamon, we have been hard pressed until recently to find any 15N20 thicker than about .057. The most common size that I have seen is .049. Some guys stack as many as 3-4 pieces of that stuff into one layer with 3/16-1/4 plain carbon steel to get high contrast damascus. Aldo has some .072 and I saw some .103 or .125 somewhere the other day, but that is about the thickest I have ever seen. the good thing about 15N20 or its analogue 75Ni8 is that it is high carbon so you don't have to worry about how much you put in a billet unlike some of the low or no carbon stuff like 300 series stainless, 1018, 203E or pure nickel. Like Mike said, the nickels buys you a little bit of corrosion resistance, at least enough to resist etching with Ferric Chloride compared to carbon steel with no nickel.
tgraypots
Senior Member
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2011
- Messages
- 537
- Reaction score
- 0
I have enough 3/32 from a local sawmill to last me for a while right now. I've only made 3 knives from it so far, sold one and gave two (2nds) to friends, and all seem to be enjoying them. I want to work my way thru the 1075 I have on hand over next few months before I begin annealing what 15n20 I have on hand. So right now, I'm good.
Marko Tsourkan
Founding Member
- Joined
- Feb 28, 2011
- Messages
- 5,005
- Reaction score
- 34
I don't touch anything under oversize 1/8, regardless whether I am making a petty or gyuto. The optimal thickness, in my opinion is about 3.6mm to start with, for heat treating (thicker stock will retain heat uniformly while quenched, than thinner or pre-ground) and for stock removal - tang and choil area can be thicker,a adding to sturdiness of a knife. More work, but better knife (IMHO) overall.
I forgot I started this thread awhile ago. I recently finished a test knife in 15n20, a 270 gyuto with a slight convex grind. It gets plenty sharp and does seem to be a little less reactive than other carbon steels I have used. In some abuse testing I was able to get the edge to roll while cutting raw chicken thigh bones diagonally, I used a steel to literally push the roll back into place and it looks like nothing happened, so it does seem pretty tough.
Sounds good. One of the advantages of carbon steels like W2 that I have found is at typical hardness for a "field" knife, the edge will roll or dent/flatten long before it has a chance to chip out.
