As an experienced knifemaker I often see knives like this. Newer knifemakers come to me for advice, so I may have a different perspective than most of you guys. In fact I had 2 people this week show me their knives and ask for advice.
These are not knives for you guys,(and gals), but this young lady is doing things I have seen from a hundred makers at least, including myself. The smaller knives are similar to many patch knives I have seen, and would function fine to that purpose. Knives made from ferries rasps, the first one I saw maybe 30 years ago, I thought was the coolest thing ever.
Please remember too that her mentor was a blacksmith, and they have a particular way of looking at knives.
I would say that she is doing just fine for a first year knifemaker, and if I had the opportunity to meet her I would tell her all the good things she is doing, and then point out the areas for improvement, and also explain how to make those improvements. It something I do with most newer knifemakers. Knifemaking is a male dominated craft and it is always encouraging to see the ladies coming to join the fun.
Now to the question of how she made it into the Times, I would very much like to know that little secret.
Thanks,
Del