Apologies in advance for the dumb questions. I've been grappling with this problem for a little bit, and wanted to see if your greater experience could shed some light on what's happening.
I'll try to break it down objectively (as best I can):
Problem statement:
When sharpening or maintaining an edge, I can reliably get to cleanly cutting copy paper sharp, but when I move to paper towel, I'm still getting a bit of tearing, so it's not really clean cut.
Variables:
I have recently acquired the JKI 1K & 6K diamond stone set, which I'm trying to use as my core, with my goal to essentially get a reliable enough method to essentially be able to strop and finish on the 6K without the need for 1 micron diamond spray strops (which I still have, I'm just trying to see if I can learn a technique that is good enough to be able to drop the loaded strop step).
I'm typically sharpening stainless steels, and get the same behaviour on different shaped knives. Of the recent knives I was sharpening last night, this lack of paper towel sharpness was most noticeable on a VG10 petty of my wife's.
I'm guessing that if it's cleanly cutting copy paper that I have successfully deburred on the 6K? There's no burr visible, and I've recently modified my deburring method based on a number of threads that I've been reading here.
Over the last few months I've been trying to get a better deburring method, so I've recently been trialing the start at the lowest possible angle, and then increase the angle for subsequent stones and stropping. I'm aware that I'm still early on in this journey, so the angle that I'm ending stropping at is probably higher than I would have preferred (mainly as I'm finding it challenging knowing what my angle "was" on the previous stone so I'm likely overcompensating by raising the angle up more than is needed), but that change in method / approach has certainly helped my deburring (I just need more practice in reducing the degree of increase). So I guess it's possible that I'm stropping at a higher angle, thereby making the apex larger, and maybe the apex is too large to cut paper cleanly?
The paper towel that my wife buys is some strange cross wave weave (Viva brand) paper towel, so I guess it's possible that maybe some of the tearing is the fibers on a different grain angle to the way I'm cutting? So maybe I could try a different brand of paper towel?
I have struggled in the past with angle consistency, and I think this is something that I'll continue to work on for as long as I'm sharpening. Making the move across to the diamond stones though, and rationalising my sharpening stones and methods has meant that there's less strokes, which has statistically reduced the impact that angle inconsistency was having much earlier in my sharpening journey. The change to increase the angle between stones / stropping is somewhat of a compensation for angle inconsistency on earlier stones, in that I'm less likely to end up with a significantly rounded apex at say 12 degrees per side, if I'm ending up stropping at a higher angle, say 25 degrees per side (again, I know this should be lower, but I just don't have a lot of confidence when the differences are so minute). But for completeness I'm guessing that angle inconsistency is a potential possibility or contributing factor in my inability to cleanly cut paper towel off stropping on a 6K diamond stone.
The 1K and 6K diamond stones are well flat, so it's unlikely it's surface inconsistency.
It may well be possible that I just have unreasonable expectations of both my approach and my ability, and cleanly cutting paper towel might not be a reasonable expectation straight off a 6K stone. That would be a great outcome for me (and give me a bit more peace of mind), however I do think that's quite unlikely given the heap of other videos of you guys sharpening that I've seen, and I'm always keen to learn, so hence I thought I'd ask the question.
I'm fully aware that for cutting the products that I'm typically doing (mainly veg), the degree of sharpness that I can already achieve is more than sufficient, so I'm guessing this is me trying to understand what needs work in my technique, and what's reasonable to expect.
Any suggestions or pointers are greatly appreciated. Let me know if there's some info that I've missed in the above.
I'll try to break it down objectively (as best I can):
Problem statement:
When sharpening or maintaining an edge, I can reliably get to cleanly cutting copy paper sharp, but when I move to paper towel, I'm still getting a bit of tearing, so it's not really clean cut.
Variables:
I have recently acquired the JKI 1K & 6K diamond stone set, which I'm trying to use as my core, with my goal to essentially get a reliable enough method to essentially be able to strop and finish on the 6K without the need for 1 micron diamond spray strops (which I still have, I'm just trying to see if I can learn a technique that is good enough to be able to drop the loaded strop step).
I'm typically sharpening stainless steels, and get the same behaviour on different shaped knives. Of the recent knives I was sharpening last night, this lack of paper towel sharpness was most noticeable on a VG10 petty of my wife's.
I'm guessing that if it's cleanly cutting copy paper that I have successfully deburred on the 6K? There's no burr visible, and I've recently modified my deburring method based on a number of threads that I've been reading here.
Over the last few months I've been trying to get a better deburring method, so I've recently been trialing the start at the lowest possible angle, and then increase the angle for subsequent stones and stropping. I'm aware that I'm still early on in this journey, so the angle that I'm ending stropping at is probably higher than I would have preferred (mainly as I'm finding it challenging knowing what my angle "was" on the previous stone so I'm likely overcompensating by raising the angle up more than is needed), but that change in method / approach has certainly helped my deburring (I just need more practice in reducing the degree of increase). So I guess it's possible that I'm stropping at a higher angle, thereby making the apex larger, and maybe the apex is too large to cut paper cleanly?
The paper towel that my wife buys is some strange cross wave weave (Viva brand) paper towel, so I guess it's possible that maybe some of the tearing is the fibers on a different grain angle to the way I'm cutting? So maybe I could try a different brand of paper towel?
I have struggled in the past with angle consistency, and I think this is something that I'll continue to work on for as long as I'm sharpening. Making the move across to the diamond stones though, and rationalising my sharpening stones and methods has meant that there's less strokes, which has statistically reduced the impact that angle inconsistency was having much earlier in my sharpening journey. The change to increase the angle between stones / stropping is somewhat of a compensation for angle inconsistency on earlier stones, in that I'm less likely to end up with a significantly rounded apex at say 12 degrees per side, if I'm ending up stropping at a higher angle, say 25 degrees per side (again, I know this should be lower, but I just don't have a lot of confidence when the differences are so minute). But for completeness I'm guessing that angle inconsistency is a potential possibility or contributing factor in my inability to cleanly cut paper towel off stropping on a 6K diamond stone.
The 1K and 6K diamond stones are well flat, so it's unlikely it's surface inconsistency.
It may well be possible that I just have unreasonable expectations of both my approach and my ability, and cleanly cutting paper towel might not be a reasonable expectation straight off a 6K stone. That would be a great outcome for me (and give me a bit more peace of mind), however I do think that's quite unlikely given the heap of other videos of you guys sharpening that I've seen, and I'm always keen to learn, so hence I thought I'd ask the question.
I'm fully aware that for cutting the products that I'm typically doing (mainly veg), the degree of sharpness that I can already achieve is more than sufficient, so I'm guessing this is me trying to understand what needs work in my technique, and what's reasonable to expect.
Any suggestions or pointers are greatly appreciated. Let me know if there's some info that I've missed in the above.